Thursday, October 17, 2019

TrashContractcontraryto CommerceRights of Citizens VOTENO SAVEOUR CHARTER

https://www.twincities.com/2019/10/16/supreme-court-decision-on-st-paul-trash-lawsuit-in-a-nutshell/?utm_source=listrak&utm_medium=email&utm_term=Supreme+Court+decision+on+St.+Paul+Trash+lawsuit%2c+in+a+nutshell&utm_campaign=stpaul-morning-report&utm_content=manual


The court said the $27 million-per-year contract would remain intact, as would all of its associated costs and obligations. However, the city may have to do some legal scrambling to create new ordinances around billing and enforcement.
Bottom line: St. Paul is still on the hook for $27 million to the trash haulers next year.
JusticeGilda,Lillhaugh,Chutxx,Hudson,Anderson etal


New Questions How can the City now set the Rates for Trash Hauling File #: Ord 19-67 Version: 1 Name: Type: Ordinance Status: Second Reading In control: City Council Final action: Title: Amending section 220.05 of the Legislative Code to set rates for base level garbage service to be effective January 1, 2020. Sponsors: Amy Brendmoen Date Name District Opinion Comment Action 10/17/2019 10:24 AM CandidateSharonAnderson Against For years Council has set Rates for NonProfit District Heating, now setting Rates for Trash a for Profit Business creates Contract Impairment, contrary to Private Citizens to do Business http://taxthemax.blogspot.com therefore creating a Monoply,AntiTrust
Ord 19-67122OrdinanceAmending section 220.05 of the Legislative Code to set rates for base level garbage service to be effective January 1, 2020.Not availableVideo Video


A19-0916        Bruce Clark, et al., Respondents, vs. City of Saint Paul, et al., Appellants.
                         Ramsey County.
            1.   A referendum on a Saint Paul ordinance that establishes organized waste collection services does not conflict with the requirements in Minn. Stat. §§ 115A.94–.941 (2018), that municipalities ensure that residents have waste collection services including through appropriate local controls, because ordinances that are not subject to the referendum fulfill those requirements and the Legislature intended that municipalities have broad authority in the process for establishing organized waste collection. 
            2.   A referendum on an ordinance that establishes organized waste collection services in the City does not impair the City’s contract obligations under the Contract Clauses of the United States and Minnesota Constitutions.
            Affirmed.  Chief Justice Lorie S. Gildea.
                                                vs.
https://www.stpaul.gov/file/documents/media-root/final-signed-contract


On Oct 16, 2019, at 9:52 AM, SharonQuiTamAnderson <sharon4anderson@aol.com> wrote:
  http://depos-stpaul.blogspot.com Trust Fund Cash Cow4Lawyers.
The agency’s powers are subordinate to the Minnesota and US constitution and Minnesota law defines; for legal purposes in determinations of fact and law; acceptable interpretations of words in statutes:


                  Wed.16Oct.2019

to the above named     Watching KSTP channel 5 re Trash
                        Candidate Sharon  http://sharon4council.blogspot.com
apparantly heard wrong that City was setting the Rates for Trash Haulers
called 651-266-8560 Mayor 266-8510
                       Can't find on legistar  the Citys Rate Setting on this Trash Issue
                 Affiant further State and Allege
                  How can the  City St. Paul,MN set the Rates 1983 up to the present
for the NonProfit District Heating,
                  Then apparantly the City maybe setting the Rates via Illegal Contract for the 6 or 7 Trash Haulers all for Profit. Interfering with Citizens Rights to Commerce for themselves.
                           ON MOTHERS GRAVE 1984, Sharon Council Candidate
                              both thrown in Jail,  http://crimes-against-humanity.blogspot.com
                My Mother Bernica A. Peterson ran for Mayor exposing the Tax Exempt Status of District Energy/heating, Coal Producing, Polluting the Downtown Air
  


The ordinance up for vote only outlines the rules for the trash program. Mayor Melvin Carter has said voting it down will not get rid of the system entirely.  
It's been about seven weeks since the Supreme Court upheld the decision to put it on the ballot.
The court’s rationale is expected to be released on Wednesday.

RES PH 19-294145Resolution-Public HearingApproving the request of District Energy St. Paul, Inc. to amend District Heating rates for fiscal year 2020.Not availableVideo Video
RES PH 19-293146Resolution-Public HearingApproving the request of District Energy St. Paul, Inc. to amend District Cooling rates for fiscal year 2020.Not availableVideo Video


S 19-1597111Excessive/Abatement Services May 22 to June 21, 2019ResolutionApproving the 
RECity’s cost 
City of Saint Paul - File #: RLH AR 19-91

File #:RLH AR 19-91    Version:   Name:Excessive or Abatement Service Feb 20 to Mar 21, 2019
Type:Resolution LH Assessment RollStatus:Passed
In control:City Council
Final action:9/18/2019
Title:Ratifying the assessments for Excessive Use of Inspection or Abatement services billed during February 20 to March 21, 2019. (File No. J1911E, Assessment No. 198318)
Sponsors:Amy Brendmoen
Ward:Special Tax Assessments
Attachments:1. Assessment Roll J1911E Mailing 7.16.2019
Related files:RES 19-1066RLH TA 19-618RLH TA 19-640RLH TA 19-639RLH TA 19-624RLH TA 19-697RLH TA 19-600RLH TA 19-645RLH TA 19-684
 Add New Comment
Date NameDistrictOpinionCommentAction
9/17/2019 5:05 PMCandidateSharonAndersonWard2AgainstUse of ***essments without decending to particulars then placing Liens on Propertys is Anti-Trust, Constitutionality of Consent Agenda http://sharon4council.blogspot.com probably 88 propertys involved Amy Brendmoen aka Mrs Jeff Neske aka 2nd Husband Mike Hahm Dirctor Parks and Rec Conflicts,Ponzi Revenue Raising Schemne to Steal Propertys without Quiet Titles, Marketable and Valid Complaints Naming Who,What and When DSI Inspectors?
zzz



Sharon Anderson aka Scarrella 651-776-5835 sharon4anderson@aol.com
LEGAL NOTICE: /s/Sharon4Anderson@aol.com ECF_P165913Pacersa1299 telfx: 651-776-5835:
Attorney ProSe_InFact,Private Attorney General QuiTam Whistleblower, www.taxthemax.blogspot.com 

The Electronic Communications Privacy Act, 18 U.S.C. 
Ch.119 Sections 2510-2521 et seq., governs distribution of this "Message," 
including attachments, may contain the originator's
proprietary information. The originator hereby notifies
recipients Message review, dissemination, copying, and content-based 
actions. Authorized carriers of this message 
shall expeditiously deliver this Message to intended recipients.  See: Quon 
v. Arch

Wednesday, September 18, 2019

SharonsObjectionCouncilAgendaWed182019AmysFundraiser7HeatherPlSt.Paul


Subject: Check out City of Saint Paul - Meeting of City Council on 9/18/2019 at 3:30 PM

                             Wed 18Sept2019
To the Aboved Named; Council,Candidates,City,County Attorneys enbanc;
                                  Sharons Objections for decades must tract on the Graves
                                    of Tenants in Common Sharons Legal Homestead
                                    1058 Summit Ave. St. Paul,MN
                                    TAKEN 4 8THOUS TAXES WHICH WERE PAID, NO mortgage
        
                          MINNESOTA, City St. Paul, City Mpls, Sanctuarys
                              taking Revenue from Homegrown Citizenery and
                              granting preferiental disparate treatment of illegal
                              immigrants.  https://citizenery-mncourts.blogspot.com/


                   Affiant Candidate Ward 2 Sharon Anderson , Donald Trump Republican, apparantly the Dark City St. Paul,MN has sold their Soul in their personal and official capacitys  by their Questionable Endorsements of Muslin Keith Ellison  use of the Quran thereby forcing Sharia Law on the Soverign Homegrown Citizenery,
                                           use of the Consent Agenda to steam roll Garbarge,Trash propertys.
                             use of Leg. Hearing Officer Marcia Mormond to have hearings
perhaps of all 6 thousand Trash Objectorshttp://saintpaultrash.com/
  November 5, 2019 -- Referendum Ballot Question
Should Ordinance ORD 18-39, entitled

                                ISSUES OF OBJECTIONS
                          a. Raising Revenue on the Backs of the Propertys Owners,
                                 creating Propertys as Debtors,
                                    i. Excessive Inspections without marketable,Quiet Titles,names of DSI inspectors. etc.




                   Gives Notice of Objections to
SR 19-98131Refugee Resettlement AgenciesStaff ReportPresentation by representatives of the Refugee Resettlement Agencies of Minnesota regarding the 2020 “Presidential Determination” for refugee resettlement.
                                 
City of Saint Paul - Meeting of City Council on 9/18/2019 at 3:30 PM

RES 19-155914Mogadishu Sister City resolution amendmentResolutionAmending RES 19-800 formalizing a Sister City agreement between the City of Mogadishu and City of Saint Paul to include the Somali American Peace Council.

RES 19-143715 Resolution
Acknowledging receipt of District Energy St. Paul, Inc. notice of rate increase as of October 1, 2019, and directing the Office of Financial Services, the City Attorney’s Office, and City Council Operations to review and analyze the rate changes.
 Years ago
 1983 Challenge  Tax exempt up to 2019
Secret Meeting with Council without Findings of Facts or Conclusions
.ROW ASSESSMENTS

similar to

also

Items Garbage Bills 6 thro 17
see Eric Lein Video at the Wed. 11Sept2019

113 RLH AR 19-74 Ratifying the assessment for the City's cost of providing Collection of Delinquent Garbage Bills for services during January to March 2019. (File No. CG1902A1, Assessment No. 190101)

                             Not sure what propertys Lein Family has altho apparantly 114 units?
Resolution LH Assessment RollStatus:Passed
  In control:City Council
  Final action:9/11/2019
Title:Ratifying the assessment for the City’s cost of providing Collection of Delinquent Garbage Bills for services during January to March 2019. (File No. CG1902A1, Assessment No. 190101)
Sponsors:Amy Brendmoen
Attachments:1. Assessment Roll CG1902A1 Mailing 6.25.2019
Related files:RES 19-210RLH TA 19-523RLH TA 19-500RLH TA 19-515RLH TA 19-541RLH TA 19-514RLH TA 19-501RLH TA 19-519
 Add New Comment
Date NameDistrictOpinionCommentAction
9/17/2019 5:17 PMCandidateSharonAndersonWard2 Against
Shocking Ignorance of City Council Enbanc Mr.Leins testimony transposed,embedded to http://sharon4council.blogspot.com
Jane Prince also a Lawyer stated to Mr Lein on the advise of Cousel have to approve ***essments even tho Prince agreed that something has to be done with Sharing,Billings etc. Mr Lein stated Constitutional Questions unabated by Council and their Lawyer Rachel Tierney
   
9/11/2019 11:05 AMEric Lein (#3 of 3) Against/// COURT RULING. On August 22, 2019, the MN Supreme Court overruled the City’s claim and decided that the Petition for a referendum is NOT preempted by MN Statutes, is NOT an unconstitutional interference, and does NOT conflict with state public policy. /// THEREFORE: The referendum is on the ballot, AND customers are owed refunds plus compensation. /// PLEASE lay over, cancel, and/or withdraw RLH-AR-19-74, RLH-AR-19-86, and all other azsessments for the City’s cost of providing Collection of Delinquent Garbage Bills for services during January to March 2019.   
9/11/2019 11:04 AMEric Lein (#2 of 3) Against/// PETITION IS LEGALLY SUFFICIENT. On November 14, 2018, RES 18-1922 was adopted, “Finding the Petition for a referendum of ORD 18-39 is legally sufficient….” HOWEVER, in an attempt to bypazs the Charter’s longstanding requirements, the City Council: (1) refused to suspend ORD 18-39, and (2) refused to place ORD 18-39 on the ballot, claiming (in error) that, “…the subject matter of the Petition is preempted by Minnesota Statutes §§ 443.28 and 115A.94, is an unconstitutional interference with the Agreement between the City and the Consortium, and conflicts with state public policy…”   
9/11/2019 11:02 AMEric Lein (#1 of 3) Against?? PAYMENT DUE TO CUSTOMERS. Trash collection fees and charges that accrued after November 14, 2018, have been and continue to be billed and enforced in error. Customers forced to pay for service they do not want should receive: (1) refunds; and (2) compensation for time spent disputing invalid charges. ?? CITY CHARTER Sec. 8.05 requires that: “Any ordinance…upon which a petition is filed…shall be suspended in its operation as soon as the petition is found sufficient. If the ordinance…is not thereafter entirely repealed, it shall be placed on the ballot at the next election…”   
xx



9/17/2019 5:05 PMCandidateSharonAndersonWard2 AgainstUse of ***essments without decending to particulars then placing Liens on Propertys is Anti-Trust, Constitutionality of Consent Agenda http://sharon4council.blogspot.comprobably 88 propertys involved Amy Brendmoen aka Mrs Jeff Neske aka 2nd Husband Mike Hahm Dirctor Parks and Rec Conflicts,Ponzi Revenue Raising Schemne to Steal Propertys without Quiet Titles, Marketable and Valid Complaints Naming Who,What and When DSI Inspectors?




RLH A
9/17/2019 5:05 PMCandidateSharonAndersonWard2 AgainstUse of ***essments without decending to particulars then placing Liens on Propertys is Anti-Trust, Constitutionality of Consent Agenda http://sharon4council.blogspot.com probably 88 propertys involved Amy Brendmoen aka Mrs Jeff Neske aka 2nd Husband Mike Hahm Dirctor Parks and Rec Conflicts,Ponzi Revenue Raising Schemne to Steal Propertys without Quiet Titles, Marketable and Valid Complaints Naming Who,What and When DSI Inspectors?   

                        Sharon has no problem with Amys Fundraiser, as 7 Heather pl is fully Homestead
9 bedrooms, 2 unrelated persons, as owners, both lawyers,
Magner v. Gallagher (10-1032) | LII Supreme Court Bulletin | LII / Legal Information Institutedroom with 2 unrelated lawyers. contrary to the Secret Deals by Tom Perez in the

 The United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit reversed in part, stating that Gallagher’s disparate impact theory presented a valid FHA claim. The Eighth Circuit applied a three-step burden-shifting test to the disparate impact claim, and found on the first step that Gallagher had satisfied its burden: Gallagher provided sufficient evidence to establish that the City’s housing code, while facially neutral, had reduced low-cost housing, resulting in a
                            Sharons Dis

Schaaf v. Trane U.S., Inc.

District of Minnesota, mnd-0:2012-cv-02465

MEMORANDUM OF LAW & ORDER. IT IS HEREBY ORDERED: Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment {{11}} is DENIED IN PART and GRANTED IN PART as follows: Count 1: Disability Discrimination in Violation of the MHRA, and Count 3: Violations of the FMLA are DISMISSED, and Count 2: Age Discrimination in Violation of the MHRA, REMAINS. (Written Opinion). Signed by Chief Judge Michael J. Davis on 4/21/14.


  Tracking amy Brendmoen aka Mrs. Jeff Neske aka Mrs. Mike Hahm
              Fundraiser owners are Lawyers Halunen and Duddingston interesting Case signed off by Federal Judge Michael Davis
                      Wonder if these Lawyers owner of 7 Heather Pl St. Paul are gay and if the Judge knew they live together a
.s Halunen represented Plt susan Schaff and Duddingston rep Trane US inc.?

CASE 0:12-cv-02465-MJD-FLN Document 29 Filed 04/21/14 Page 1 of 48
SUSAN SCHAAF
,
Plaintiff,
v.
MEMORANDUM
OF LAW & ORDER
Civil File No.
12-2465 (MJD/
FLN
)
TRANE U.S., INC.,
Defendant.
Clayton D. Halunen, Barbara Jean Felt, and Ross D. Stadheim, Halunen &
Associates, Counsel for Plaintiff.
David J. Duddleston and Sara G. Sidwell, Jackson Lewis P.C.
, Counsel for
Defendant
.
I.
INTRODUCTION
This matter is before the Court on Defendant’s Motion for Summary
Judgment. [Docket No. 11] The Court heard o
ral argument
on
November 14,
2013. For the reasons that follow, the Court grants in part and denies in part
Defendant’s motion.
II.
BACKGROUND
A.
Fact
ual Background
CASE 0:12-cv-02465-MJD-FLN Document 29 Filed 04/21/14 Page 1 of 48



at 7 Heather Pl St. Paul,MN
Beacon - Ramsey County, MN  

 Parcel IDOwnerProperty Address
 012823320280CLAYTON HALUNEN DAVID DUDDINGSTON7 HEATHER PL

Tax Classification1A-Residential Homestead

Image may contain: house, sky and outdoor


claimer;
267Excessive or Abatement Service Feb 20 to Mar 21, 2019Resolution LH Assessment RollRatifying the assessments for Excessive Use of Inspection or Abatement services billed during February 20 to March 21, 2019. (File No. J1911E, Assessment No. 198318)


xx
Sharon Anderson aka Scarrella 651-776-5835 sharon4anderson@aol.com
LEGAL NOTICE: /s/Sharon4Anderson@aol.com ECF_P165913Pacersa1299 telfx: 651-776-5835:
Attorney ProSe_InFact,Private Attorney General QuiTam Whistleblower, www.taxthemax.blogspot.com 

The Electronic Communications Privacy Act, 18 U.S.C.
Ch.119 Sections 2510-2521 et seq., governs distribution of this "Message,"
including attachments, may contain the originator's
proprietary information. The originator hereby notifies
recipients Message review, dissemination, copying, and content-based
actions. Authorized carriers of this message
shall expeditiously deliver this Message to intended recipients.  See: Quon
v. Arch

Search This Blog

Worth Reading Headline Animator